Awesome, affordable, dine-in Mai-Tais below:

Note: I like to substitute Grand Marnier for the Curacao, and I like to add a bit of fresh lime juice (pick the free limes on the hill to the south of the cottage), and a dash of club soda.
Put the ice in first, then add the ingredients in order listed and do not stir. The layers are the flavors.

But if you are going out: Fleetwoods in Lahaina (order the Mai Tyler), and Merrimans and Monkey Pod (don’t forget your wallet!)